
Cleaning-catch-basins to help NYC reduce flooding seems to be “a thing” right now. It’s a growing response to more flooding, a hyper-local tactic with clear appeal.
But with 154,000 catch-basins in NYC, will we find 154,000 good people to clean them before 20 storms a year? That would be ~3M catch-basin cleanings annually.
So, it is a positive thing people can do. But is it a good city-wide strategy? And are there some potential unintended consequences of pushing it?
It’s fall in NYC. The usual trash is now mixed with fallen leaves.
Add a hefty rain storm = more flooding.
We it saw again last week. And it’s not just “nuisance flooding” - it can quickly get bigger than that; in fact at this time a year ago, two people drowned in in NYC basement apartments.
Some flood videos from Nov 12 rain:
A quick answer to “what can I do?”
More New Yorkers want to do something about flooding and there are many good people out there willing to jump in to clean catch-basins.

The city is asking us to do it:

Source: Notify NYC
People doing it are getting praised:
Community groups help organize efforts:
Major new stories about it:
The NYT did a recent story about Valeen Bhat, a Brooklyn small business owner, who is a vigilant catch-basin cleaner and whose flooding story we shared a year ago…and it continues.
And many DO get clogged:
According to a Rebuild By Design analysis of 311 data over the last 4 years, there were 35,348 reports logged on clogged catch-basins. These reports help the city prioritize where to send cleaning trucks (and $ more trucks was just approved).
So The Positives Are Clear
leaves and trash do block the top
simple and seeable (unlike some flooding causes)
there are examples of it working (we see water going down)
before / after satisfaction; feels good (hey, at least we did SOMETHING!)
AND…there are benefits in just getting people together to care for their community, something NYU Sociologist Eric Klinenberg and author of Can Sponge Cities Save Us calls “social infrastructure” which he says is a key component of resilient neighborhoods
Ok, So Why Question It
As much as I see the benefits of catch-basin cleaning, and I have participated and promoted it…something recently made me wonder: is it helping, or actually hurting? What is making me re-think it a bit.
Freakonomics:
In 2005, two economists wrote a book called Freakonomics which focussed on how incentives drive human behavior, how it can play out in weird ways and why that can explain that things don’t always work out as planned and even have the opposite effect.

Good intentions may clash with incentives
Unintended consequences
Upstream / Downstream
Sometimes the opposite happens
Example: a daycare had a problem with parents picking up kids late and teachers having to work extra hours. They wanted kids picked up on time and so they started charging a “late fee” for anyone who showed up late forcing teachers to stay. They assumed adding the extra penalty cost would reduce late pickups.
But the opposite happened. Instead of decreasing, late pick-ups surged.
Why? The book explains it well but basically it has to do with replacing a moral imperative with a transactional incentive that gave people permission to do un-intended things that were trying to be curtailed. The main point is: it had the opposite effect…and there are others examples like that in the book.
How does this apply to catch-basins:
Could the focus on catch-basin cleaning have the opposite effect on what we want: which is to reduce flooding in NYC?
Some points to consider below.
More water in an old sewer may not stop flooding but just push it: With storms exceeding 2 inches per hour, flooding in NYC isn’t likely helped by rushing more water into ~154,000 catch-basins which feed an old sewer system with capacity limits of 1.5 - 1.7 inches per hour. Rivers get wider quickly but pipes don’t. DEP admits expanding sewer pipe volume alone won't keep up with the pace of water forecasted.
Encouraging people to send it there: Pushing the idea that our sewers can handle more if we just unclog them may actually create more flooding nearby and downstream to people a bit lower in the sewer-shed area.
Sometimes the sewer IS the source of our flooding: When sewers are overwhelmed by bigger cloudbursts, it can trigger widespread sewer backups into our homes and small businesses; Moreover, it often leads to combined-sewer-overflow (CSO) discharge of millions of gallons of raw sewage into our shoreline coast (see Queens/BK Newtown Creek example).
Clog maybe below: Catch-basin cleaning clearly can help in some spots - and reduces what likely falls below. But they only work if sewer isn’t already full and the lower part is also clog free. The city did get more trucks for that, but there are a LOT of places to clean and hard to send trucks out to locations where cloudburst locations are less predictable (where 311 data collection helps).
It’s work and good people burnout: When people clean catch-basins (sometimes repeatedly), and report things on 311 (sometimes repeatedly), but they still see water on top of drains, or that flooding continues…or even just seeing the catch-basins you cleaned last week covered again this week…well, that blossoming civic effort can wear out and curdle into civic resentment, or just exhaustion.
Dis-incentive to other solutions: If people see a catch-basin on their street is “clear”, are they less likely to take OTHER steps to protect their home or building? Before you think I’m crazy, there is a study of New Orleans shows when people see Levees built they tend to drop flood insurance. OR does a clearing catch-basins reinforce some people feeling it’s fine to sump pump their basement water onto the street?
A distraction from real solutions: Should we consider de-emphasizing cleaning catch-basins and “up-emphasize” micro-mitigation solutions that divert and hold water away from old narrow NYC sewers - or at least slow it down so the sewer has time to catch up? There are lots of ways to use green and grey infrastructure to help yourself and the city and we have written about many in The City Sponge and working on a new flood solutions help portal called Blue Dots. But it takes attention, an alignment of incentives (there’s that word again) and very often money.
Where should our focus be:
To be fair, the city is not just talking about catch-basins: they are doing MUCH more as we have cited in other posts. They do study this in detail (NYC Stormwater Report 2024).
On this topic, however, we have heard the Adopt-A-Catch-Basin pilot started by DEP is currently “being assessed.” Perhaps there are questions about repeatability and scale…
In a busy NYC where people only give you so much attention, the risk of putting more of emphasis on cleaning catch-basins is it can distract us from more systematic solutions that may have bigger impact on helping our tight sewer systems and reduce flooding:
Like not doing laundry, dishwashers, showering during a storm
Like using that time to point your sump pump AWAY from street
Like adding and maintaining more green infrastructure that absorbs water
Like facilitating neighborhood plans to optimize public and private spaces, from medians and curbs, downspouts and tree beds, to parking lots with porous pavement or even local basketball courts with tanks underneath
Like helping tens of tens of thousands do retro-fits in older homes, small businesses and street-level houses of worship.
On that last point - and again applying “Freakonomics” thinking here - when will NYC align incentives between the city and private building owners, like they do in other cities:
154,000:
Again, I see the positives and appreciate the people who step up and clean our streets, for many good reasons beyond just flooding.
But will we find 154,000 good people to clean our 154,000 catch-basins in NYC across 20 storms a year? 3M catch-basin cleanings annually? Probably not.
For those reasons listed above, maybe we should turn that good will and energy towards lasting flood solutions and reduce our reliance on a few very good people with very good intentions.
While it feels good short-term, it can also be busy work that distracts us from focussing on scaleable solutions. And it could have the opposite effect of what it is intended to do…the “Freakonomics” of catch-basin cleaning.
The Mayor Sees Need
The Mayor is seeing flooding as a major factor, and acknowledged recently that about a third of his term so far has been under flood emergency warnings.
The city has been pursuing many approaches: from big capital projects that take many years, to using parks as sponges, to smaller innovative things like detention tanks under basketball courts and rain gardens on bus stops .
Now let’s take that innovation and scale it to the hundreds of thousands of smaller older building across NYC. We can wait for something like a flooding version of Local Law 97 (accelerating retro-fits for electrocution and carbon removal in NYC), or we can just do it because we don’t want to freak out every time it rains.
Communities Pursuing Solutions
SE Queens
Highlights from “Flood Solutions Saturday” in SE Queens where homeowners went on a guided journey from risk to solutions. Organized by Southeast Queens Residents Environmental Justice Coalition (SQREJC), the day included an overview of inside/outside solutions, a local documentary on flooding, insurance advice, funding programs, assessments, native plants, and a local green infrastructure tour of examples in the area. Click here or image below to see more.
East Bronx
On the anniversary of Hurricane Sandy, the Waterfront Alliance along with The City Sponge, Bronx River Alliance, YMPJ, City Island Rising, City Councilor Farias, Representative Ocasio-Cortez, Ctr for NY Homeownership, NHS, city agencies and local trades came together as experts - from plumbing to policy - to help people find flood solutions that work for them and their area. See the POV from City Councillor Amanda Farias OR for more click here or flyer below.
Greenpoint
Highlights from the discussion with 350 Brooklyn, Eymund Diegel CSI (“Creek Scene Investigator”), The City Sponge, and the Greenpoint Library and Environmental Education Center. See the main points and slides in this summary.
Astoria
Lots of NYC places are trying to manage flooding, including parks. Highlights from our Flood Solutions Walk ‘n Talk at Socrates Sculpture Park in Astoria Queens. Artist Lizania Cruz set up an “Ecologies or Care” interactive exhibition there where people can express their attitudes on the future of climate in NYC. With support from MOMA. A few pics and video clips here.













